Skip to content

Rental Investment: Calculating Yield and Returns

If you’re considering buying a rental property, understanding yield and returns is essential. Many investors buy properties that look good on paper but don’t actually generate positive cashflow.

Gross rental yield is the annual rent divided by the property price, expressed as a percentage.

Example: property worth AUD 500,000 rents for AUD 2,000/month (AUD 24,000/year). Gross yield = 24,000 / 500,000 = 4.8%.

Net rental yield accounts for costs: rates, body corporate fees (if apartment), maintenance, insurance, property management, and vacancy allowance.

Using the same example:

  • Gross rent: AUD 24,000/year
  • Less: rates (AUD 2,400), insurance (AUD 1,200), body corporate (AUD 3,600), property management (AUD 2,400), maintenance (AUD 1,500), vacancy (AUD 1,200)
  • Total costs: AUD 12,300
  • Net operating income: AUD 24,000 - AUD 12,300 = AUD 11,700
  • Net yield: 11,700 / 500,000 = 2.34%

This is very different from the gross 4.8%. Many investors quote gross yield (which is misleading) and don’t account for the actual costs.

Cashflow is different from yield. Yield is a return on the property value; cashflow is the money left in your pocket after all expenses and mortgage repayments.

Example:

  • Gross rent: AUD 24,000/year
  • Costs (as above): AUD 12,300
  • Mortgage repayment: AUD 32,000/year (for a AUD 400,000 loan at 4.5%, 25-year term)
  • Cashflow: 24,000 - 12,300 - 32,000 = -AUD 20,300

Negative cashflow! You’re paying AUD 20,300 per year out of pocket to own this property.

Is negative cashflow bad? Not necessarily. Some investors buy for capital appreciation (betting the property value rises faster than costs/mortgage), not for cashflow. But you need to be aware of the true cost.

A positive cashflow scenario:

Property: AUD 400,000 Loan: AUD 300,000 (25% down, AUD 75,000) Rent: AUD 2,500/month (AUD 30,000/year) Costs: AUD 11,000/year (rates, insurance, maintenance, vacancy) Mortgage: AUD 16,500/year (AUD 300,000 at 4.5%, 25 years) Cashflow: 30,000 - 11,000 - 16,500 = AUD 2,500/year

Positive cashflow! You’re making AUD 2,500 per year on this property, and you’re also building equity as you pay down the mortgage.

Key metrics to evaluate:

Gross yield: should be at least 4%–5% for a property to be interesting.

Net yield (after costs): should be at least 2%–3%.

Cashflow: positive is good; negative is okay if you’re betting on capital appreciation, but understand the cost.

Price-to-rent ratio: divide property price by annual rent. A ratio of 20 or lower suggests good value (20 × annual rent = price). A ratio of 25+ suggests the property is expensive relative to rental income.

Capital appreciation: even with negative cashflow, if the property appreciates 5% per year (AUD 20,000 on a AUD 400,000 property), you’re making money overall. But don’t count on it.

Strategy:

When evaluating an investment property:

  1. Calculate true costs (get rates, insurance, and property management quotes)
  2. Calculate mortgage repayment for your intended loan size
  3. Determine expected rent (ask local agents, check rental sites)
  4. Calculate net cashflow
  5. Decide if you can afford negative cashflow or if you need positive

Many investors who encounter financial stress bought properties with heavy negative cashflow and couldn’t absorb it when income dropped. Be realistic about your capacity.

The best investment properties generate positive cashflow, appreciate in value, and allow you to build equity. They’re harder to find but worth the search.