Skip to content

Getting Mortgage Advice from a Broker vs. Going Direct to Banks

When you’re ready to apply for a mortgage, you have two main paths: apply directly to a bank or use a mortgage broker. Each has advantages and trade-offs.

Going directly to a bank:

Advantages:

  • You know who you’re dealing with (a major bank with regulation and customer protection)
  • You might feel confident in a big institution
  • Some people prefer simplicity and directness

Disadvantages:

  • You’re only seeing that bank’s products and rates
  • Banks take longer to process applications (weeks, often)
  • Banks have stricter criteria and less flexibility
  • You’re not getting neutral advice—the bank wants to approve you for as large a loan as possible
  • You might miss better rates or terms elsewhere

Using a mortgage broker:

Advantages:

  • Brokers access multiple lenders (banks, non-bank lenders, credit unions), so you see more options
  • Brokers often get approval faster (they’re efficient and have direct relationships with lenders)
  • Brokers are incentivized to find you the best deal (they earn commission from lenders, so happy customers mean more referrals)
  • Brokers can advise on loan structure, features, and long-term strategy
  • Brokers often find better rates than direct bank applications (because they have leverage with multiple lenders)
  • If you have a complex situation (self-employed, credit issues, unusual circumstances), brokers know which lenders will work with you

Disadvantages:

  • You don’t deal directly with the lender (though brokers are licensed and regulated)
  • Some brokers have preferences for certain lenders (though good brokers try to be neutral)
  • You need to choose a reputable, licensed broker

Cost:

This is a common question: does using a broker cost you money? The answer is usually no. Lenders pay brokers a commission (typically 0.5%–1% of the loan value). You don’t pay this directly—it’s built into the lender’s economics. You get broker advice for free.

That said, always confirm there’s no up-front fee. Reputable brokers earn commission from lenders; unreputable ones might charge you upfront fees that you don’t fully understand.

Comparison:

You apply directly to a bank:

  • Interest rate quoted: 4.75%
  • Approval: 4 weeks
  • Loan structure: standard (no special features)
  • Cost: AUD 500 application fee + valuation fee

You apply through a broker:

  • Interest rate quoted: 4.45% (broker shopped multiple lenders)
  • Approval: 2 weeks
  • Loan structure: tailored with offset account, redraw, rate-lock features
  • Cost: zero (broker commission paid by lender)

The broker path is faster, cheaper, and nets you a better rate.

Strategy:

  1. Talk to 2–3 brokers and compare their approach and recommendations
  2. Even if you go with a broker, check one major bank’s rate (to confirm the broker is competitive)
  3. Ask your broker which lenders they’re recommending and why
  4. Get recommendations from friends or online reviews for reputable brokers

Red flags in a broker:

  • Unwilling to discuss fees upfront
  • Pushing one lender exclusively without explanation
  • Not providing written recommendations
  • Pressuring you to apply immediately

Good brokers:

  • Explain options clearly
  • Answer questions transparently
  • Provide written comparisons
  • Listen to your goals and tailor recommendations
  • Follow up after settlement to ensure you’re happy

For most borrowers, a broker is the better path. They’ll save you time, money, and stress. The only reason to go direct is if you have a very simple situation and a specific bank offers an exceptional rate.

Take advantage of broker services. It’s a free tool that works in your favor.