Skip to content

Fixed vs. Variable Rate Mortgages: Weighing the Trade-Offs

One of the first decisions you’ll make with a home loan is whether to fix your interest rate or go with a variable rate. It’s not a one-size-fits-all choice—it depends on your risk appetite and financial situation.

A fixed-rate mortgage means your interest rate is locked in for a set period (typically 1–10 years). During that period, regardless of what happens to market rates, you pay the same interest rate. Your repayments are predictable and stable.

A variable-rate mortgage means your interest rate fluctuates with the market. When the RBA raises the official cash rate, your mortgage rate usually increases. When it cuts, your rate typically falls. Your repayments change accordingly.

Which is right for you?

Fixed rates suit you if:

  • You want certainty and predictability (you budget to the dollar)
  • You expect interest rates to rise
  • You prefer the peace of mind of a locked-in rate
  • You’re stretching financially and want to avoid payment shocks

Variable rates suit you if:

  • You have financial flexibility and can absorb payment increases
  • You expect interest rates to fall
  • You want to capture the upside if rates drop
  • You plan to refinance or sell before the rate environment changes significantly

Let’s look at costs. Fixed rates are typically 0.25%–0.75% higher than variable rates. This premium reflects the lender’s cost of hedging interest rate risk. If you lock in a 4.5% fixed rate while variable rates are 4.0%, you’re paying 0.5% extra for the certainty.

Here’s the maths. On a AUD 500,000 loan, a 0.5% rate difference is AUD 2,500 per year (AUD 208 per month). Over a 5-year fixed term, that’s AUD 12,500 in extra interest. Is the certainty worth AUD 12,500? That depends on your situation.

If interest rates rise to 5.5% during your fixed term and stay there, you’ve saved money—the fixed rate was the right choice. If rates fall to 3.0%, you’ve overpaid. You can break the fixed rate early (most lenders allow this), but you’ll pay a break fee, usually AUD 2,000–AUD 5,000.

A hybrid approach: some borrowers split their loan. You might fix 50% of the loan for 5 years and leave 50% on a variable rate. This gives you some certainty while maintaining some flexibility. As fixed terms expire, you can refinance, renew, or switch to variable.

Another consideration: loan features. Variable-rate loans typically allow you to make extra payments without penalty, redraw funds if you need them, and change your repayment frequency. Some fixed-rate loans restrict these features. Check what you get with each option.

Rate lock features: some lenders offer a “rate lock” option where you fix a rate for a short period (e.g., 60–90 days) while you shop for a property or finalize your purchase. This protects you if rates rise while you’re arranging finance.

The practical approach: look at your financial situation. If you’re comfortable with uncertainty and have a buffer, variable rates offer flexibility and often save money. If you value certainty and want predictable repayments, fixed rates are worth the premium. Talk to your broker about both options and run the scenarios—how would your budget look if rates rose 1%, 2%, or 3%?

Neither option is universally “better.” The right choice depends on your circumstances and risk tolerance.